Newcastle, Oklahoma, steeped in rich history, was established in 1962, making it a relatively young city compared to its counterparts. Nestled in McClain and Grady Counties, Newcastle was initially a small agricultural community that thrived due to its proximity to the Chisholm Trail, the famed 19th-century cattle drive route. Over time, the city transformed from a humble rural settlement into a bustling center of trade and commerce, with the Oklahoma Railway Company’s introduction in the early 1900s playing a crucial role in its expansion.
Newcastle’s small-town charm and modern conveniences attract residents and visitors. The city is good for raising a family because of its great schools, low crime rate, and strong community. Newcastle residents and visitors have many leisure and recreational options due to its closeness to Oklahoma City. Outdoor enthusiasts may fish, hike, and boat in the city’s lush parks, lakes, and calm Canadian River.
Below we explore several of Newcastle’s very own foodie destinations and the meals that are known as staples of the community!
7 Must-try Restaurants in Newcastle
Not listed in any particular order, but definitely worth visiting!
Kitchen 44
Kitchen 44, open daily, is the ideal dining destination for those seeking a delightful combination of fast, convenient service and mouthwatering culinary creations. The menu boasts an impressive array of satisfying dishes, including po’boys, sandwiches, melts, and burgers, as well as country classics available all day long. To elevate your dining experience, be sure to pair your meal with their signature 44 sauce, which adds an extra punch of flavor to any dish.
Located on the east end of the North building, Kitchen 44 provides a welcome respite from the bustling Newcastle Casino floor with its rustic reclaimed wood, cozy booths, and relaxed atmosphere. Its quick service ensures that patrons can return to their favorite gaming machines without missing a beat, making it the perfect pit stop for a delicious meal amidst a fun-filled day or night.
Luigi’s Bistro
Luigi’s Bistro at Westbury, the West Metro’s best-kept secret, is a family-owned and operated Italian-American restaurant nestled within the OakHaven community in Westbury. With a rich history dating back to 1951, when Luigi Scaffetta first introduced his Italian cuisine at The Hide-A-Way in Batavia, New York, the restaurant continues to honor the tradition of being family-owned and operated. Today, Luigi’s family revives his signature appetizers, pizzas, entrees, and desserts to offer authentic, homemade Italian cuisine to the communities of Mustang and Yukon.
Owner Jorge Chavira emphasizes the restaurant’s dedication to cooking everything fresh, ensuring that every item on their extensive menu is prepared right in the restaurant. The menu, which includes a variety of steaks, burgers, pizzas, lasagna, spaghetti, desserts, and more, caters to a wide range of tastes. Luigi’s Bistro at Westbury takes immense pride in serving the local community and maintaining its locally-owned and operated status, making it a true hidden gem in the area.
Creek Bottom Burgers & BBQ
This restaurant in the Tri-City/Newcastle area, west of I-44 on HWY 37, serves a variety of tasty dishes. The restaurant caters special occasions and is known for their mouthwatering Grilled Onion Smash Burger, Hand Cut Fries, Brisket, Pulled Pork, and Ribs. They focus on fresh ingredients to give exceptional taste and lift their game to make customers happy.
Open for dine-in seating from Monday to Friday, 11 am to 8 pm, the restaurant also accommodates call-in orders for pick-up through their side window, as well as drive-thru orders for customers who don’t mind waiting. Amidst the current challenging times, they express gratitude for their customers’ understanding and support. Their signature Hand Cut Fries are a must-try, with chef Chase’s dedication to achieving the perfect crispy and salty combination, guaranteeing patrons will be back for more.
JP’s BBQ
Newcastle, Oklahoma’s famed walk-up BBQ shop JP’s BBQ sells pork, brisket, ribs, and smoked sausage. The stand’s BBQ, sandwiches, bacon, and brisket are among the city’s best. JP’s BBQ’s delicious cuisine has a 4.6 Google rating.
The stand’s chopped brisket draws rave reviews. Their menu includes pig, bacon, sausages, brisket sandwiches, and salads, so there’s something for everyone. Newcastle BBQ lovers must visit JP’s BBQ for a substantial dinner or a quick bite.
Taqueria Los dos Hermanos
Taqueria Los dos Hermanos, located in Newcastle, Oklahoma, is a fast-food truck offering fresh and authentic Mexican cuisine. Open daily, the truck serves an array of delicious menu items, including Steak, Burrito Mexicano, Arroz con Pollo, Carne Asada, Ground Beef Nachos, Large Queso Dip, and Enchiladas Verdes. Their flavorful dishes have garnered a strong following and positive reviews from patrons, with a 4.4 rating from 374 DoorDash ratings.
Customers have praised the quality and taste of the food served at Taqueria Los dos Hermanos, with many sharing their satisfaction in reviews. Heather P appreciated the great tacos and tasty queso, despite some stale chips. Manuel C, another satisfied customer, deemed it the best Mexican restaurant they’ve ordered from and expressed excitement to visit the spot in person in the future. Taviaira J also enjoyed the tacos and loved the queso dip. With such positive feedback, Taqueria Los dos Hermanos has undoubtedly established itself as a go-to destination for mouthwatering Mexican cuisine in Newcastle.
GG’s Country Cooking
GG’s Country Cooking in Newcastle, Oklahoma, has garnered praise for its fantastic food and excellent service. Patrons have raved about the delicious menu items, such as the chicken fried steak, hash browns, eggs, biscuits and gravy, and the Big Daddy burger with fries. In addition to the mouthwatering cuisine, the restaurant’s prices are also noted to be reasonable. Satisfied customers have expressed their eagerness to return and even document their meals with photos during future visits.
In addition to the great food and service, GG’s Country Cooking has earned a reputation for their exceptional kindness and hospitality. One customer recounted an experience where the restaurant staff went above and beyond to help when their spouse fell ill just outside the establishment. The staff dropped everything to assist, even going so far as to bring a cold towel to the parking lot for the couple. This compassionate act is a testament to the warm and welcoming atmosphere at GG’s Country Cooking, making it a must-visit dining destination in Newcastle.
Taco Mayo
Taco Mayo, located in Newcastle, Oklahoma, is committed to providing fresh, accurate, and fast service to its customers. With a mission statement and core values focused on growth and excellence, the company is continuously on the lookout for career-minded, long-term individuals who share their dedication to making Taco Mayo stand out from the competition. By fostering a work environment that values learning and teamwork, Taco Mayo aims to be a company that genuinely cares about its employees and promotes upper management from within.
They serve burritos, tacos, tostadas, salads, bowls, nachos, quesadillas, tamales, kids meals, sides, and desserts from their 35-year-old menu. Taco Mayo is a popular restaurant and a great place to work for foodservice professionals. Its senior management team has over 100 years of experience.
